About Martin & Martin Insurance

On April 1st, 1989 (no joke), Martin & Martin Insurance opened its doors as an Erie Insurance Agency in the spare bedroom of Jack and Chris' small Carmel home. Fast forward 32 years, five different offices, and 14 Erie Excellence Awards later, Martin & Martin is now located in the heart of "Hipstoric" Downtown Noblesville Indiana.

With over 30+ years of service in the Noblesville community we have continued to adapt and embrace technological advances, while our dedication to old-fashioned customer service has remained constant. 


Martin & Martin wins the 2021 F.W. Hirt Quality Agency Award Winner

Martin & Martin Insurance Agency, recently won the 2021 F.W. Hirt Quality Agency Award. This is the highest award an agency can receive from Erie Insurance. The Quality Agency Award is presented to an agency that models all that is best in a successful insurance agency including profit, growth, tenure, attitude, education and consistency. 

 Let's Discuss Your Insurance Coverage

We know that there are many ways to purchase insurance these days, we appreciate the fact that you are considering Martin & Martin!


Martin & Martin Insurance Testimonials

"Incredible customer service and wonderful people. Always fast to respond and thorough with their explanations. Great company!"
Steve - 15 years with M&M

"Great service- they make it easy & simple for everyone."
Mary - 17 years with M&M

"They have always been there ready to help if we needed to file a claim...Always polite. Always personalized attention."
John - 13 years with M&M




Visit the Martin & Martin Insurance Office in Downtown Noblesville

Martin & Martin Insurance Agency, 62 S 9th St, Noblesville, IN
Phone 317-773-3743 / Text 317-674-3173
Office Hours - Monday - Friday 9:00am - 4:30pm
(Fur-babies welcome)


Sorry, this website uses features that your browser doesn’t support. Upgrade to a newer version of Firefox, Chrome, Safari, or Edge and you’ll be all set.